| 
  • If you are citizen of an European Union member nation, you may not use this service unless you are at least 16 years old.

  • You already know Dokkio is an AI-powered assistant to organize & manage your digital files & messages. Very soon, Dokkio will support Outlook as well as One Drive. Check it out today!

View
 

Week_4

Page history last edited by marina gonzalez 13 years, 3 months ago

Welcome to Week 4

Developing our own action research.

 

 

During this week:

  1. We will discuss important mentoring issues.
  2. We will organise ourselves into groups of interest. 
Activities
  1. Discussion topic a: what makes a mentor in TESOL different from any other one (life mentors for example)?
  2. Discussion topic b: let us share opinions on the role of the mentor and his/her relationship with other authority figures.
  3. eluminate conversation session (to be confirmed)

Comments (16)

shefali_ray@hotmail.com said

at 3:40 am on Feb 2, 2011

One key element in the role of the mentor is trust. The mentor needs to keep confidential the discussions with the mentee or his/her observations about the mentee. During our project, the mentors had to be careful not to discuss the sensitive aspects of the mentee's career or performance with others (least of the all the coordinator or the school head or even me who was their 'super mentor'). Discussions were held taking up issues or cases with no names or specifics so that the mentee did not feel threatened or embarrassed in any way. Confidence is one of the key elements in a supportive role as a mentor.

Anne Fox said

at 6:25 am on Feb 2, 2011

One thing which interests me particularly is how to introduce mentoring in a situation where it does not exist. You can't stand up in the staffroom and say 'Who'd like to be my mentee?' so my question is about how can it be introduced into an institution? I imagine that in certain circumstances it can be a private arrangement and that in other circumstances it is an institution-supported policy and that there are all sorts of shades of grey in between. I'd really like to know if it's possible to introduce mentoring effectively at anything below institutional level. Perhaps as a a pilot to convince the management to later adopt it instituion wide.

marina gonzalez said

at 9:59 am on Feb 2, 2011

If I may be of any help, I want to share with you soem conversations I've had on the issue. We had an online chat with Gagriel Diaz maggioli and my ELTManagement studetns on professional development, and it was surprising to see that my students were asking development to be given to them while Gabriel was trying to help them see PD starts within you. SO, Yes, I would say that a mentoring scenario may very well imply your standing up and inviting someone to join you in the project. You can count on us to support the project, for sure, but that is the first step.
As a DoS, I started the mentroing program in the institute where I worked but mentoring can not be imposed, it creates/ comes with a certain working culture at least from a top down pèrspective, so it is not easy either. What's more, it is quite complicated from a managerial perspective because if there is no transparency it can be read as fake...
and last comment, the other week, in the tapped In chat, Angi, Val and I mentioned the fact that even if you convince the people at the Ministry of Education, it cannot efective if you don't get the idea going at classroom level. That's where I am standing right now, on how to move beyond one specific organization into a wider context.. (excuses for Typos :-)

Yuly Asencion said

at 10:51 am on Feb 2, 2011

Interesting issue. I would say that mentorship can be informally established between mentees and mentors, and then benefits of the mentorship relationships created can be brought to the attention of the administrators.

Valerie S. Jakar said

at 8:38 pm on Feb 2, 2011

This was exactly how I began a program, since I believed strongly in the mentoring process and there was no budget for such 'luxuries'. I was working with a cohort of second –careerers who were 'training' at a teachers' college on a govt. subsidized accelerated program. I encouraged each one of them to choose someone to be their mentor (a friend or a teacher at the school where they were doing their teaching practice), making it clear that there would be no remuneration, but they would have some privileges (material or 'spiritual') conferred on them by the college. In most cases , the mentees were happy with their choices and the volunteer mentors (vms) gained a great deal - not materially, but professionally. So this brings up another issue, too: how well-suited must the mentor and mentee be , and how well - or whether! – should the arrangements be engineered?
We gave the vms some peremptory training, and asked that everyone - mentors and mentees – keep a journal. We held an occasional forum, where the mentors could share their ideas, woes, and general information (not the confidential parts) about their mentees.
A strong bond built up between the mentors , and the second careerers became a strong cohesive group.
Fortunately, although we used much of the format of the model for the following year, we were able to get some financial remuneration for the mentors of the next cohort because the Ministry of Education decided to invest in mentoring programs in a few districts, in order to reduce the attrition. And it did!
How did people hear about the success? Because some participants conducted an Action Research Study which was published in a local newsletter, Which brings us back to the value of AR in our mentoring enterprise!

Benjamin L. Stewart, PhD said

at 9:02 am on Feb 2, 2011

Within an EFL context, a mentor facilitates or coaches a mentee in any combination of the following (depending on the need): (a) becoming a better communicator of the English language, (b) increasing one's pedagogical skill, and (c) increasing one's knowledge of how languages are learned. This contrasts a nonTESOL mentor/mentee relationship that only focuses on pedagogical skill and knowledge of the subject.

marina gonzalez said

at 10:05 am on Feb 2, 2011

That would be a non tesol mentor but within the field of education, right?
From the many mentor uses,the one that cosntantly come s to my mind is the one of life mentor, now I realize it is hard for me to focus on the differences because I am more attracted by the qualities mentors may have in common than by thier differences. What's more, I feel that differences may be more given by the predominant role the scenario sets to them (acculturator, sprokesperson, etc.) than by the nature of their mentoring. What do you all think? thanks in advance for your enlightening words!

Yuly Asencion said

at 10:49 am on Feb 2, 2011

How intimidating for the mentee is to be coached in L2 language use? Should a mentor coach on L2 issues?

Benjamin L. Stewart, PhD said

at 12:09 pm on Feb 2, 2011

I think it would depend on how the mentor approaches it. I don't think it has to be intimidating.

Valerie S. Jakar said

at 8:49 pm on Feb 2, 2011

It seems (from our experience) that being a teacher in the same discipline is only preferred for the high school and fiurther ed. teachers , whereas in the elementary and junior high school sectors, knowledge of the particular discipline is not valued; classroom management and general procedural knowledge are more important. However, when the teacher (novice/struggling) is a non native speaker of English ( to use the 'old' nomenclature) there is a stronger desire to be mentored by a native (-like) English speaker.This obtains all the up to Uni. level teachers. I suppose this is what Ben is referring to when he notes the differences in focus.

Benjamin L. Stewart, PhD said

at 12:11 pm on Feb 2, 2011

Yes, nonTESOL mentor within the field of education.

Anne Fox said

at 4:58 pm on Feb 4, 2011

Thanks for these positive reports. Maybe the more one to one or personal approach can be achieved by making the mentoring process less formal and more personal.

Valerie S. Jakar said

at 9:57 pm on Feb 5, 2011

Yes Anne, but remember, there should always be limits set - by both parties. Early on in the process , a concensus should be reached and articulated. A number of my trainee mentors in the past reported overdependence, and invasion into the mentor's private domains. It's a fine line to be drawn but it's helpful .

Valerie S. Jakar said

at 10:10 pm on Feb 5, 2011

Returning to the issue of mentoring for Teachers of ESOL, we should give our attention to the plights and hardships of declared non-native speaking teachers of English.Where do people stand on this? What are the mentors to do if they feel that their mentees could use more English in the classroom? And how do they deal with a mentee who is told by students or parents of students that they are of less value to them because they don't have native-(like) English.?

shefali_ray@hotmail.com said

at 10:10 am on Feb 6, 2011

In India, English is a second language and all around in the environment. Yet most of the teachers of English, need to hone their skills in the language so that they can use it fluently in the classroom. The thought that an English teacher ought not to make a mistake or have errors can be quite stressful for teachers of ESOL. This prompts the teacher to take recourse to the use of the learners' own language for ease of comprehension and efficiency of managing the time in the class.
Since Indian English is considered a genre of English , there isn't much pressure on the teacher to speak like the 'native speaker'.

Valerie, you mentioned the overdependence and inavasion into the mentor's private domains. Could you tell us something more about it? Does that happen when the mentoring process is more personal?

shefali_ray@hotmail.com said

at 10:19 am on Feb 6, 2011

Many amongst the English teachers in India would have learnt English from their pre-primary classes. They are fluent in the language and need help in pedagogical aspects. But there are some who have had a much briefer and a less intensive exposure to English in school themselves and by virtue of a degree obtained in English (which is primarily literature based with focus on the reading and writing skills) get appointed as English teachers. They need to develop their skills of communication in English, especially the oral skills. Hindi, the national and a major language has a flexible syntax and, often when the teacher thinks in Hindi and tries to translates that into English she has a problem.

You don't have permission to comment on this page.